• Question: How does researching how the earth started aid our lives in moving forwards in society? When surely we could spend that time doing other experiments and researching into other topics?

    Asked by The_Legitimate_Callux to Angela, Claire, Ian, Robert, Sarah on 19 Nov 2014.
    • Photo: Ian Cade

      Ian Cade answered on 19 Nov 2014:


      What do you mean ‘moving forwards in society’? how do you plan to measure what seems to be a fairly nebulous concept?

      Your question gives the impression that you think future problems and their solutions can be predicted with perfect clarity… (for example, “we know x, y and z are important problems” and “we know that x’, y’, z’ are the best solutions to thee problems”… how do you propose we might know this?)

      Science just doesn’t work like this! A famous quote runs like this:

      “If we knew what we were doing, it wouldn’t be called research, would it?”

      Essentially, we can’t predict what will be useful so we just research everything we can. Fortunately, it turns out that a general understanding of the universe is generally useful, and discoveries in one area can have entirely unexpected applications in another.

    • Photo: Sarah Harris

      Sarah Harris answered on 19 Nov 2014:


      I agree with Ian – all research can have practical applications, we just might not know what that is at the time! It’s quite a common question though; a lot of people ask why we’re focussing on earth origins and space travel when there are so many issues on earth to be addressed.

      For example CERN, which is investigating higgs boson (the particle they think is responsible for the big bang), is also where the world wide web was developed, and that was just because the scientists wanted a way to share their research and information with other organisations. That’s had a massive impact on society!

    • Photo: Angela Stokes

      Angela Stokes answered on 19 Nov 2014:


      Hi there
      Your question is a bit like asking why do we study history, surely we should concentrate on the future. The thing is when we study history we see what has gone before, what didn’t work, what caused unrest etc and it is the same with science. By studying how the earth was formed we gain insights into how it may behave in the future, where the undiscovered volcanoes might be, where we might find a new fuel source, what has changed since then and now etc. So our history so often gives us clues to our future so it is important to study both…….even if the new things seem more exciting!!

    • Photo: Robert Bowles

      Robert Bowles answered on 21 Nov 2014:


      This is the best response to this question I’ve ever seen.
      http://scienceblogs.com/startswithabang/2012/08/07/with-all-the-suffering-in-the-world-why-invest-in-science/

Comments